Oksana Ilchenkov

 

Article

Title of the article

THE EFFECT OF PUNISHMENT AND CRIME RATES IN THE WEST AND RUSSIA

Authors

Helmut Kury

University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany

Oksana Ilchenko

Far Eastern Federal University, Vladivostok, Russian Federation

   

Year

2013

Issue

2

Pages

73-81

           

Abstract

Since old times it is the rule to prevent undesirable, especially criminal behaviour by punishment. In medieval times most brutal sanctions are used - and as was the obvious result also in that times, with no or small effect. At the same time, the attitude to the punishment has never been straightforward. Beccaria wrote that we should "prevent crimes than to punish them"; it means that criminal prevention must be concentrate in "rewarding virtue." The scientist also believed that "in countries and over time with the most severe punishment most brutal crimes had been done." The effect of criminal sanctions is small, if ever given. This is shown on the background of empirical research from the USA, Finland, Germany, Switzerland and Portugal and on the basis of different groups of criminal behaviour. All international empirical results show a missing or in best cases small crime preventive effect of sanctions. The reasons are discussed. Alternatives to harsh sanctions mostly are cheaper than and as successful as sharp punishments. Nevertheless crime politicians are asking for sharper punishments, here populist ideologies might play an important role.

Keywords

Violent crime; Punishment; Brutal sanctions; Decriminalization; Rehabilitation   

You can access full text version of the article.

You can access full text version of the article.

Bibliography

1.       Agra C. da 2009. Requiem pour la Guerre à la Drogue. L'Expérimentation Portugaise de Décriminalisation. Déviance & Société. 33, 27-49.

2.       Aos S. 2003. Cost and benefits of criminal justice and prevention programs. In: Kury, H., Obergfell-Fuchs, J. (Eds.), Crime Prevention - New Approaches. Mainz: Weisser Ring, 413-442.

3.       Beccaria C. 1764; 2005. Von den Verbrechen und von den Strafen. Berlin: Berliner Wissenschafts-Verlag.

4.       Blumstein A., Wallman J. (Hrsg.). 2006. The crime drop in America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

5.       Bowers W.J., Pierce, G.L. 1980. Deterrence or Brutalization: What is the Effect of Executions? Crime and Delinquency. 26, 453-492.

6.       Braman D. 2004. Doing Time on the Outside: Incarceration and Family Life in America. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.

7.       Death Penalty Information Center (2011). The Death Penalty in 2011: Year End Report (http://deathpenaltyinfo.org/documents/2011YearEnd.pdf). 

8.       Death Penalty Information Center (2012). The Death Penalty in 2012: Year End Report (http://deathpenaltyinfo.org/documents/2012YearEnd.pdf).  

9.       Dölling D., Entorf H., Hermann D., Rupp T. 2011. Meta-Analysis of Empirical SAtudies on Deterrence. In: Kury, H., Shea, E. (Eds.), Punitivity - International Developments. Vol. 3, Bochum: Universitätsverlag Dr. Brockmeyer, 315-378.

10.    Gascón G., Foglesong T. 2010. Making Policing More Affordable. Managing costs and Measuring Value in Policing. Washington: National Institute of Justice.

11.    Gilinsky J.I. 2002. Kriminology. Piter Press.

12.    Greenwald G. 2009. Drug Decriminalization in Protugal. Lessons for Creating Fair and Successful Drug Policies. Washington, D.C.: Cato Institute.

13.    Hinds L. 2005. Crime control in Western countries, 1970 to 2000. In: Pratt, J., Brown, D., Brown, M., Hallsworth, S., Morrison, W. (Eds.). The New Punitiveness. Trends, theories, perspectives. Portland/Oregon: Willan, 47-65.

14.    Hofer H. von, Tham H. 1975. Beware of General Prevention! In: National Swedish Council for Crime Prevention (Hrsg.). General Deterrence - A Conference on current Research and Standpoints. Stockholm: Research and Development Division, 257-270. 

15.    Jasch M. 2003. "Zero Tolerance" in New York - Was ist daraus geworden? Frankburg: unveröff. Manuskript.

16.    Kury H. 1979. Sozialstatistik der Zugänge im Jugendvollzug Baden-Württemberg. Freiburg: Max-Planck-Institut für Strafrecht. Unveröff. Forschungsbericht.

17.    Kury H. 2001. Das Dunkelfeld der Kriminalität. Oder: Selektionsmechanismen und andere Verfälschungsstrukturen. Kriminalistik 55, 74-84.

18.  Kury H., Kern J. 2003a. Frauen und Kinder von Inhaftierten. Eine vergessene Gruppe. Kriminologisches Journal 35, 97-110.

19.  Kury H., Kern J. 2003b. Angehörige von Inhaftierten - zu den Nebeneffekten des Strafvollzugs. Zeitschrift für Strafvollzug und Straffälligenhilfe 52, 269-278.

20.  Kury H., Quintas J. 2010a. Zur Wirkung von Sanktionen bei Drogenabhängigen - Argumente für eine rationale Drogenpolitik. Polizei & Wissenschaft 1, 31-56. 

21.  Kury H., Quintas J. 2010b. Sanktionen oder Hilfe? Einstellungen zu Drogentätern - Ergebnisse aus Portugal. Kriminalistik 64, 403-409.

22.    Kury H., Sato M. 2013. Bewährungshilfe - die Rolle der Freiwilligen. Ein Vergleich zwischen Deutschland und Japan. Zur Veröff. Eingereicht.

23.    Lappi-Seppälä T. 2011. Changes in Penal Policy in Finland. In: Kury, H., Shea, E. (Hrsg.). Punitivity - International Developments. Vol. 1: Punitiveness - a global Phenomenon?

24.    Lauterbach O. 2009. Jugendstrafvollzug - Soziale Integration und Delinquenz nach Entlassung aus dem Jugendstrafvollzug. ZJJ - Zeitschrift für Jugendkriminalrecht und Jugendhilfe 20, 44-50.

25.    Lilly J. R., Knepper P. 1993. The Correctional-Commercial Complex. Crime and Delinquency 39, 150-166.

26.    MacKenzie D.L. 1998. Criminal Justice and Crime Prevention. In: Sherman, L.W., Gottfredson, D., MacKenzie, D.L., Eck, J., Reuter, P., Bushway, S., Preventing Crime: What waorks, what does not, what is promising. Washington: National Institute of Justice.

27.    Males M., Macallair D., Taqi-Eddin K. 1999. Striking Out: The Failure of California's «Three Strikes and You're Out" Law. San Francisco: Justice Policy Institute (http://www.cjcj.org/files/strikingout.pdf).

28.    Males M., Macallair D. 2010b. Are Teenage Criminals Getting Younger and Younger? Exposing another Urban Legend. San Francisco: Center on Juvenile & Criminal Justice.

29.    Murray J., Farrington D.P. 2008. The Effects of Parental Imprisonment on Children. In: Tonry, M. (Hrsg.). Crime and Justice. Chicago: Chigano University Press. A Review of Research, 37, 133-206.

30.    Ortmann R. 1993. Prisonisierung. In: Kaiser, G., Kerner, H.-J., Sack, F., Schellhoss, H. (Hrsg.), Kleines Kriminologisches Wörterbuch. Heidelberg: C.F. Müller, 402-409.

31.    Pauwels L., Weerman F., Bruinsma G., Bernasco W. 2011. Perceived sanction risk, individual propensity and adolescent offending: Assessing key findings from the deterrence literature in a Dutch sample. European Journal of Criminology 8, 386-400.

32.    Quintas, J., Agra, C.da. 2008. The impact of Portuguese Drug Use Decriminalisation Law. Porto: University of Porto, Faculty of Law - School of Criminology.

33.    Radelet M.L., Lacock T.L. 2009. Recent Developments - Do Executions lower Homicide Rates?: The Views of Leading Criminologists. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 99, 489-508.

34.    Rose D.R., Clear T.R. 1998. Incarceration, Social Capital and Crime: Examining the Unintended Consequences of Incarceration. Criminology 36, 441-479.

35.    Shelden R.G. 2010. The Prison Industry. San Francisco: Center on Juvenile & Criminal Justice.

36.    Snell T.L. 2010. Capital Punishment, 2009 - Statistical Tables. Washington: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics. 

37.    Storz R. 1992. Jugendstrafrechtliche Reaktionen und Legalbewährung. In: Heinz, W., Storz, R.: Diversion im Jugendstrafverfahren der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. Bonn: Bundesministerium der Justiz.

38.    Törnudd, P. 1993. Fifteen Years of Decreasing Prison Rates in Finland. National Research Insatitute of Legal Policy. Research Communication 8.

39.    Wikström P.-O., Tseloni A., Karlis D. 2011. Do people comply with the law because they fear getting caught? European Journal of Criminology 8, 401-420.

 

 

 

გაზიარება
დაბეჭდვა
© გრიგოლ რობაქიძის სახელობის უნივერსიტეტი   |   ვებ-საიტის შექმნის თარიღი: 2011.05.05   |   განახლებულია: 2016.09.23
თბილისი, ჯანო ბაგრატიონის 6, დავით აღმაშენებლის ხეივანი მე-13 ბათუმი, დავით აღმაშენებლის ქ. 13   |   ტელ:(+995 32) 2384406; (+995 32) 2382706   |   ფაქსი: (+995 32) 2384406   |   ელ-ფოსტა: info@gruni.edu.ge
11275338

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Created By